WiseTip › All editions › #20
#20AFreeJuly 19, 2023

Barbie, Oppenheimer, and the two conversations they opened.

The same weekend

01OpeningFree preview

Two films opened on the same weekend. One was the most commercially successful film of the year. The other was about the most destructive weapon in human history. My children wanted to see the first one. My husband wanted to see the second. We negotiated, as one does, and the outcome was that we saw Barbie on Saturday and Oppenheimer was watched at home later, in sections, with considerable pausing and explaining.

02StoryFree preview

I'm a biologist, not a film critic. But I study how children process information, and Barbenheimer — the cultural phenomenon of these two films opening simultaneously — provided one of the more interesting case studies of the summer in terms of what different kinds of content do to children's conversations.

Barbie opened a conversation about gender, identity, and the gap between how things appear and what they actually are. My daughter, twelve, had opinions. Strong ones. The conversation lasted several days and wandered into territory — what it means to be a woman, what performance is, what authenticity is — that we had not navigated together before.

Oppenheimer opened a conversation about responsibility. My son, nine, asked: did Oppenheimer know the bomb would kill that many people? I said: he knew it would kill a great many people. He said: then why did he make it? And we were in a question that philosophers have been asking for eighty years, at the dinner table on a Tuesday evening.

The mechanism I'm describing is not specific to summer blockbusters. It works with news events, with books, with any shared cultural experience that creates a common reference point. The shared reference is the entry point — the thing that makes the conversation possible. Without it, the topic has to be introduced directly, and direct introduction is almost always less effective.

← #19All editions#21 →